Tai Chi, balance and falls
Can Tai Chi help older adults fall less often?
There is high-quality evidence that a designed Tai Chi balance programme can reduce falls among community-dwelling older adults at high risk. A 2018 randomised trial in JAMA Internal Medicine enrolled 670 people aged 70 or over who had fallen in the past year or whose mobility was impaired. After 24 weeks, twice a week, therapeutically oriented Tai Chi had a fall incidence about 58% lower than stretching and about 31% lower than multimodal exercise. That is a result of a Tai Chi programme, not a completed clinical trial of any practice machine.
What the trial compared
All three groups met twice a week for about 60 minutes, for 24 weeks. The Tai Chi group used Tai Ji Quan: Moving for Better Balance, Tai Chi and balance movements modified for therapeutic needs, not a video of one traditional routine. Controls were multimodal exercise and a stretching-based control. At six months there were 152 falls in the Tai Chi group, 218 in the multimodal group and 363 in the stretching group.
A later analysis also looked at injurious falls. Relative to stretching, the incidence rate ratio for serious injurious falls in the Tai Chi group was about 0.25. The investigators counted fall events, not a score on a screen.
The earlier Atlanta FICSIT study (Wolf et al., 1996) had already reported an association between Tai Chi and a lower risk of repeated falls. The 2019 Cochrane review found that exercise which includes balance and functional practice can reduce falls in community-dwelling older adults. Tai Chi is one widely studied form.
Balance research in Hong Kong
Research by William Tsang and Christina Hui-Chan at the Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, found measurable improvement in balance control after four to eight weeks of relatively intensive Tai Chi. Long-term practitioners also did better than less-practised peers of the same age on knee proprioception, limits of stability and knee strength. These are sensorimotor studies. The sample and the forms differ from the 2018 falls trial in the United States.
How a service should not cite this
Do not write “falls will fall by 58% after this system is installed”. The 58% belongs to that Tai Chi programme compared with stretching. The product gives posture and movement feedback during the Tai Chi 12 forms, Baduanjin and Yijinjing, so staff and practitioners can see the movement. It does not replace a falls-risk assessment, and there is no falls trial that used this machine as the intervention.
A sentence that can go into a service plan is: in balance training for older adults at high risk of falls, therapeutically oriented Tai Chi outperformed stretching alone; this unit will run a group in the Tai Chi 12 forms, Baduanjin or Yijinjing with a therapist or trained staff present, and will monitor with clinical tests such as the Timed Up and Go, rather than replacing those tests with an artificial-intelligence score.
Sources
- Li et al., JAMA Internal Medicine, 2018; 178(10):1301-1310.
- Follow-up analysis of injurious falls.
- Sherrington et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2019, CD012424.
- Tsang and Hui-Chan, four- and eight-week Tai Chi and balance in older adults, Hong Kong Polytechnic University.