Online and on-site practice
What is the difference between online Tai Chi videos and on-site practice?
Online video and live streaming solve “people can see a demonstration and start at home”. They cannot see each person’s centre of mass, step length or knee direction clearly. A community class has an instructor and other participants; quality depends on whether the instructor can watch people one by one. A clinical group has screening, but therapist time is limited. An on-site routine system places the demonstration and movement feedback inside the unit, for use while staff are present. A person still has to decide whether that service user can stand safely.
What is commonly done now
Public videos and social-media follow-along can be watched at any time. There is no individual correction, and a wrong movement can be repeated. In a live stream the instructor is present, but the picture is small and the centre of mass is hard to judge. In-person classes run by the Leisure and Cultural Services Department, elderly centres and Department of Health education have social and cultural acceptance, but class quality and instructor experience vary, and an objective record for each person is rare. Clinical groups in hospitals and health centres have professional judgement, and the staff cost of commenting on every movement is high.
What this system adds, inside that last layer, is detail of the form. In front of a 21.5-inch touchscreen all-in-one, the practitioner works through the Tai Chi 12 forms, Baduanjin or Yijinjing. A multimodal movement model analyses posture and detail and gives artificial-intelligence feedback. It does not replace an instructor, and it does not turn an online video into a clinical assessment.